Magic: The Gathering Buying Guide: What to Buy First for Playing or Collecting
← All Magic: The Gathering guides
The best first Magic purchase is the one that produces the game you want to play. A box full of cards can be exciting and still leave you without a useful deck, an opponent, or a clear next step. Start with the question “Who will I play with, and what are they playing?”
For two people learning together, choose a teaching product. To join a Commander group, choose a complete Commander deck suited to that table. To play a specific Constructed format, begin with a legal deck list. To enjoy opening packs, choose a spending limit and treat the opening as entertainment rather than a plan to obtain specific cards.
Match the purchase to your first session
| Goal | Useful starting point | Check before buying |
|---|---|---|
| Learn with a friend | A Beginner Box or suitable two-deck Starter Kit | Exact edition, included teaching materials, and whether it supports two players |
| Join multiplayer Commander | One complete Commander preconstructed deck | Exact deck name, contents, complexity, and the group’s expectations |
| Build your own small decks | A known card collection or a planned singles list | Lands, copy counts, and the format you are building for |
| Play with fresh packs | A Draft, Sealed, or Jumpstart session | Correct pack type, player count, and required basic lands |
| Collect artwork or a favorite character | Selected singles or a bounded sealed opening | Exact printing, treatment, condition, and total budget |
For two new players: buy a teaching experience
A useful teaching product does more than supply cards. It reduces the number of decisions before the first game, explains setup, and gives both players something to play. The Foundations Beginner Box includes guided learning materials and predetermined themed packets. Its role is to get you playing, not to supply a tournament-ready deck.
A two-deck Starter Kit can also make sense, especially if its theme interests both players. Check the exact edition: deck lists, teaching aids, and digital bonuses vary. Do not assume an old listing includes currently valid codes, or that a product with “starter” in its name has identical contents to another starter product.
If only one of you owns cards, agree on the first session before buying. Two beginner-level decks played repeatedly are more useful than one highly tuned deck facing whatever the other person can assemble. Keep the decks intact for a few games so that learning a card once pays off later.
For Commander: buy the whole deck you want
A Commander precon is a ready-built deck for that format. It is the direct route into a group already playing Commander, provided the table welcomes it and can explain multiplayer rules. Check that the listing is the complete deck, not just its commander card, an accessory, a collector sample pack, or an empty display box.
Choose by the deck’s plan as well as its face character. Making creature tokens, reanimating cards from the graveyard, and managing spell-copy triggers create different kinds of first games. A theme you love can justify learning more complexity, but it helps to know what you are taking on.
Play the unmodified deck several times before ordering upgrades. Write down whether it struggled to find lands, draw cards, answer threats, or finish the game. Those observations create a useful shopping list. An online list of powerful cards can increase cost without fixing the reason your deck stalled.
For a specific format: price a list before a box
Standard, Pioneer, Modern, and Pauper have different card pools. A current booster can contain cards that matter in several of them, but that does not make a random box an efficient way to assemble one deck. Identify the list, check legality, then work out which cards you already own and which copies you still need.
Singles let you buy the card and quantity your plan requires. Compare the least expensive suitable printing if you care about play rather than a particular treatment. Include shipping and seller minimums when comparing a scattered order with buying locally. The lowest displayed card price is not always the lowest delivered total.
Before joining an event, confirm its format with the organizer. “Friday Night Magic” describes an event program, not a guarantee that every store is playing the same format. Avoid choosing a deck for a format that your local group rarely plays.
Understand the booster names
Play Boosters are intended for their set’s Limited environment as well as opening for fun. Collector Boosters emphasize treatments and collectibility; they are not a necessary upgrade for playing. Older Draft Boosters were built for drafting, while older Set Boosters focused on opening. Contents vary by release, so those names are categories rather than a universal card-count promise.
Jumpstart uses themed packets that include lands and combine into decks according to the product’s instructions. A teaching box’s predetermined packets are not necessarily the same product as a randomized retail Jumpstart booster. Do not buy them expecting identical themes, cards, or legalities.
A Bundle typically combines packs with accessories and other specified contents. A Prerelease Pack supports its intended prerelease experience. Neither should be assumed to contain a finished Constructed deck. Read what is guaranteed, and separate those items from random cards you might open.
A practical budget exercise
Suppose you have a fixed amount for your first month. Divide it into an initial playable product, basic protection if needed, and an unspent reserve. Use that reserve only after playing. You may discover that your favorite part is building decks rather than opening packs, or that your friends want a different format.
For collecting, define a project before opening: one favorite creature type, a page of art you love, or selected versions of one character. A pack limit is easier to respect if you also know what happens afterward. Buying a missing single can finish a project; opening another box may only add more duplicates.
Check the listing, seller, and exact item
- Match the product name, edition, language, and deck variant to the official listing.
- Distinguish one deck or pack from a multi-item display. Photos sometimes show a range of available designs.
- Check whether the item is factory sealed, opened, repacked, or sold without accessories.
- Read seller identity, delivery terms, and return information. An official-looking photo alone does not establish authenticity.
- Do not treat a promotional card shown in old marketing as currently guaranteed. Store promotions can depend on eligibility and remaining supply.
Where to compare first purchases
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. These links open Amazon search results, not a verified individual listing. Confirm the exact product, edition, seller, and contents before ordering. A local game store can also explain its beginner sessions and help you choose something you can use there.
Buy enough to play the session you have planned. Then let the games tell you what the second purchase should be.
Official sources & further reading
Rules and product details checked against Wizards of the Coast resources. Examples and learning recommendations are B3’s own.
- Official product categories
- Foundations products
- Foundations contents and set-code differences
- Format directory
- Find a local game store